Quick answer: Lease if you drive a predictable number of miles, like having a new vehicle every few years and want a lower monthly payment. Buy if you drive a lot, like to customize, or keep vehicles for the long haul and want to build equity. In Michigan, leases are subject to the 6% tax, and the trade-in tax credit applies only to purchases.
Here's how I explain it to customers. Leasing is like renting a sharp loft downtown near the Blue Bridge: lower monthly cost, always something new, but the landlord has rules. Buying is like owning a house in Heritage Hill: more up front, but it's yours, and you can paint the walls any color you want. (You also fix the roof.) Neither one is wrong. It's about which fits your life.
How does leasing a car work?
With a lease, you pay for the part of the vehicle's value you use up during the lease, plus a rent charge and fees. In return, you get a new vehicle for a set term with a set number of miles per year. At the end, you can return it, buy it or trade it toward something new. Lower payments and always being under warranty are the big draws.
How does buying a car work?
When you buy, you pay for the whole vehicle, either up front or with a loan. Payments are typically higher, but every one builds equity. Once it's paid off, the payments stop and the vehicle is yours to keep, sell, trade or lift and put 35s on.
Leasing vs. buying, side by side
- Monthly payment: Usually lower with a lease; higher when buying.
- Miles: Leases have an annual mileage allowance; buying has no limits.
- Customizing: Limited on a lease; anything goes when you own it.
- Equity: None with a lease; you build it when you buy.
- Repairs: Leases usually stay under factory warranty; owned vehicles eventually age out of it.
- End of term: Lease: return, buy or trade. Purchase: keep driving payment-free.
- Wear and tear: Excess wear can mean charges at lease end; owners just live with the door ding from the Meijer parking lot.
How are car leases taxed in Michigan?
Michigan's 6% tax applies to leases as well as purchases. On a lease, tax is generally charged on what you pay over the lease, not the vehicle's full price, which is part of why lease payments can stay lower. One important difference: according to the Michigan Department of Treasury, the trade-in tax credit does not apply to leases.
When you buy, the trade-in credit lowers the taxable price by your trade's value, up to a cap: $12,000 for 2026, rising to $13,000 on January 1, 2027. If you have a valuable trade, that can make a real difference. Our finance team will walk you through exactly how tax applies to your deal.
Who should lease and who should buy?
Leasing may be a good fit if you:
- Drive a steady, predictable number of miles each year
- Like a new vehicle with the latest tech every few years
- Want a lower monthly payment and fewer out-of-warranty repairs
Buying may be a better fit if you:
- Drive a lot. A daily round trip from Hudsonville to downtown Grand Rapids adds up to roughly 7,500 miles a year before you even count weekend trips to Holland.
- Plan to keep your vehicle well past the payoff
- Want to customize, tow heavy or rack up off-road adventures
What happens at the end of a lease?
You have three choices: return the vehicle (and pay any excess mileage or wear charges), buy it for the purchase price in your contract, or trade it toward your next Jeep, Ram, Dodge or Chrysler. Many drivers who lease once find they like starting fresh every few years.
Talk it through with our finance team
There's no one-size-fits-all answer, and we're happy to run the numbers both ways. Browse new inventory, see our current lease options and finance specials, visit our finance center, or get pre-qualified with no impact to your credit score.
This article is general information, not tax or financial advice. Lease and finance terms are subject to credit approval.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to lease or buy a car in Michigan?
It depends on how you drive. Leasing usually means lower monthly payments and a new vehicle every few years, but with mileage limits. Buying costs more per month but builds equity, has no mileage limits and is usually cheaper if you keep the vehicle a long time.
Do you pay sales tax on a car lease in Michigan?
Yes. Michigan's 6% tax applies to leases. With a lease, tax is generally charged on what you pay over the lease rather than the vehicle's full price. Ask our finance team to show exactly how tax is applied to your deal.
Does the Michigan trade-in tax credit apply to leases?
No. Michigan's trade-in tax exclusion applies to purchases, not leases. For purchases, the exclusion is capped at $12,000 for 2026 and $13,000 for 2027.
What happens if I go over my lease miles?
You'll pay an excess-mileage charge for each mile over your allowance, as listed in your lease agreement. If you expect to drive more, choose a higher mileage allowance up front or consider buying.
Can I buy my car at the end of a lease?
Usually, yes. Most leases include a purchase option price. You can buy the vehicle, return it, or trade it toward a new one.
— Curt Campeau, General Sales Manager, Courtesy Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram